Nickel Plate Bar & Grill is the premier sports bar in Fishers, Indiana, and listed as having one of the best burgers of Indianapolis. It is bot bar and restaurant, which in Indiana means there are noth smoking and non-smoking areas! I ordered a cup of "Our World Famous Hobo Stew" ($3.99), which was extremely filled and chunky, but unfortunately also largely tasteless. I followed up with The Nickel Plate Burger (Cajun spices, grilled onions, served on grilled Texas toast; I opted out of the Hot Pepper cheese). The burger was thick, but a bit dry, the Cajun not very spicy: a decent, but not remarkable, burger. The fries were soggy but ok.
VERDICT: 78/100
The Nickel Plate Bar & Grill is a regular sports bar with regular bar food.